CMH Gourmand

Culinary Discovery & Misadventures in the Ice Cream Capital of the World (Columbus)

  • Recent Comments

    The Mega Meat Challe… on The Challenge of Joseppi…
    Mike Bussard on Susie’s Sub Shop….…
    Lana Crabtree on Tropical Nut and Fruit Company…
    Beechwold Diner | Co… on Breakfast with Nick at Beechwo…
    cmh gourmand on Arepazo (Tres) Tapas Bar &…
    Patrick on Arepazo (Tres) Tapas Bar &…
    Carolina G. on Arepazo (Tres) Tapas Bar &…
  • CMH Gourmand – “a twitter”

  • Categories

  • Top Posts

  • Archives: August 2006 to Now

Casa di Pizza: The Best Ribs for the Buck

Posted by cmh gourmand on July 18, 2011

I found out about Casa di Pizza from my dental hygienist. Over several conversations with her between spitting and mumbling in a dental chair I trusted she would only give me a good tip. When she highlighted the ribs at a pizza place I was intrigued but more than a little skeptical.

Casa di Pizza is a carry out well off the beaten path. It has an innovative service window connecting to a bar next door for constant food shuttling. The menu is more progressive than would be imagined. Beverages include Hanks Sodas and Blenheim Ginger Ale. There are three pizza sauces: Red, Creamy Alfredo and Roasted Garlic. Pizza choices include The Defibrillator, appropriately named since it is piled with pepperoni, bacon, ham, Italian Sausage and salami. For the less heart-attack inclined there is the Double Double (two layers of cheese and two layers of pepperoni) and the Chicken Cordon Bleu (Alfredo Sauce, chicken, provolone, ham and Swiss Cheese). If you are undecided you might order all fourteen toppings on the Kitchen Sink. The most unexpected combination is Ziggy’s Steakhouse mixing rib eye, steak sauce, mushrooms and hand cut fries. Speaking of the fries they are near perfect, especially if you like them state fair style, balancing just enough grease with the right proportion of potato.

Enough foreplay, it is time to cut to the chase. The ribs. The ribs are incredible. Start with the Casa Teaser Sampler of four ribs. It will make you a believer. The ribs are not technically BBQ based on how they are cooked but who cares. They are cooked in the pizza oven but I am not sure of the other special preparations for the racks and I did not want to pry. The sauce balances sweet and tangy with a stick to everything thickness that somehow does not adhere to your body parts. No wetnaps are needed. You are most likely to eat the ribs with a fork and knife or your fingers. The meat falls off the bone by the touch or a gentle breeze leaving behind a barren, white rib bone which looks like a fossil. The bones are bare – they seem to be a delivery device for the meat – nothing sticks to the bone so there is no work involved in consumption. This seems like cheating.

Are the best ribs I have ever had…..no. However these are the best value and most instantly rewarding. Considering the price, consistency, ease of eating and hours of accessibility of Casa di Pizza ribs I would almost choose over Ray Ray’s if Casa di Pizza was closer. When a pizza place nails ribs, it is worth the effort. Do you recall that I mentioned there is a bar next door? As an added bonus I will provide this tricky tip. If you can’t convince your significant other eater of the need to go to Casa di Pizza, pretend that you want to do something educational. Visit the Campbell Memorial Park just north on McKinley. The Shrum Indian Mound located there would serve as an acceptable picnic site for rib or pizza consumption.

Casa di Pizza
2986 McKinley Ave
Located in the strange netherworld between Grandview, San Margherita, Hilliard and a quarry
614.586.1342

Casa di Pizza on Urbanspoon

About these ads

4 Responses to “Casa di Pizza: The Best Ribs for the Buck”

  1. […] heads north to the New Albany Farmers Market. CMH Gourmand heads off the beaten path to score some ribs from Casa di Pizza. Street Eats Columbus features a writeup on the new Short North Bagel Deli cart (pictured above) […]

  2. DELICIOUS FOOD! I’ve never tasted anything there that wasn’t delicious!

  3. Tricia said

    Casa di Pizza is actually the Daily Deal this weekend. You can get a $20 certificate for $10. Great way to try their ribs at a discount. http://columbus.halfoffdeals.com/index.php?index_type=promo-detail&pid=134317

  4. Lorence said

    Thanks for the heads up, Jim. We’ve been driving past this place for a pretty long while (it’s not too far from home), now I have a reason to stop in!

    BTW, in that same area, closer to Trabue, is the San Margherita Market – a little dive looking place that has great subs and really nice egg rolls ($1 each!) with a nice homemade dipping sauce – looks like any other orangy-red flake filled sauce, but one bite and you’ll know the difference. Go on in, head towards the back.
    Another hidden treasure. And yes, the Mound makes a great picnic spot!
    Rosie reviewed it last year (http://rosieskitchen.blogspot.com/2010/05/where-is-hell-is-san-margherita-you-ask.html) and I’m sure that Becke did, too, but I can’t find the post, may have been on somewhere on CU.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 208 other followers