Pats Donuts & Kreme (& Pizza?!), Lima: Ohio Donut Trail
Posted by CMH Gourmand on February 20, 2019
My schedule for 2019 so far can best be described as chaotic with a strong dose of frenetic. That being the case, you will be introduced to another character in the Gourmand Universe. Long time readers are aware of the Grumpy Old Man, CMH Spouse, CMH Griffin and Mr. Suit, we now have the addition of Father of Elation (FOE).
FOE is a doctor and was sent to Lima for a week by his practice. Fortunately he had me to give him some unsolicited suggestions on how to spend his free time (away from his wife and three kids). One of the suggestions FOE did take me up on was Pats Donuts & Kreme. Pat’s has three locations in Lima. One of the locations is open 24/7 and offers pizza in addition to donuts. I knew this could create just enough interest to spur FOE into action so he was sent to do my bidding.
His report was as follows: “Pizza was quite good. Crust just the way I like it, thick and doughy but crisp.” An observation was made about how it is easier to order pizza toppings without a spouse or children present but I will not elaborate on that to keep FOE out of trouble. In regards to the donuts, the report was “…took me back to my childhood and the Holmes County institution Norman’s Bakery. I got a chocolate Creme stick and cinnamon fried cake. High marks for both.”
It should be noted that FOE fell asleep mid report and had to continue his report via text the next day.
Other items of note about Pat’s: 1) FOE did not bring any donuts back for me – so he is on probation for future scouting missions 2) Pat’s has been family owned since 1983. 3) Pat’s serves ice cream, sandwiches and other items in addition to donuts.
If you have been to Pat’s or another Lima donut institution Mello-Creme, let me know your thoughts in the comments.
CMH Gourmand - Eating in Columbus & Ohio 
Robertybob said
I grew up in Lima and would rate Pat’s and Mello-Creme equally (high) as far as donuts go. Both are homemade in store and are BIG. The choice usually comes down to which is closest…and Pat’s Elida Rd. store wins bonus points with its 24 hours of operation. BTW, Pat’s makes donuts constantly, so do not be afraid that the case will be full of stale donuts in the evening. Pat’s filled sticks are FILLED as they should be! Something some Columbus bakeries have not learned!
cmh gourmand said
I agree with the “filling” issue. Thanks for the feedback.