Many Top Ten lists are based on a criteria of one person’s opinion of what is the best or a poll for the masses that often has an aggregate of mediocre. In the world of food and drink – the best is always subjective and personal and variable. Best does not always mean the finest execution, or ingredients, or the finest person behind the counter. My Top 10 is based on what I crave. Like music, the most technically perfect singer or a master of an instrument is not always the one with the most awards or the most money. A pop star strikes a cord with people based on much more than skill or craft.
When Columbus Alive, Columbus Underground, 614 Magazine and etc., run a best of poll the internet trolls come out to complain about which the “best of” are listed. In the case of these polls the term favorite would be better served than best. Best implies quality which can be objective in the world of food and drink, but there is still a subjective component to the decisions process. For instance when best brewery is listed, the winner is more often the place that people have heard of or where they like to hang out instead of the place that most accurately brews beer that is true to style or would win the highest rankings from trained beer judges. In the case of Mexican restaurants, more often than not a chain scores the “best of” win. Objectively and subjectively a chain Mexican restaurant could not be the best in Columbus but they get the win because more people have dined at a chain than one of our great authentic Mexican restaurants in town. Condado is not the best Mexican Restaurant in town, nor Chipotle.
When I was leading brewery tours (pre-covid) people would always ask me what the best brewery was. I would respond with my typical response. “Most of them are my friends so where I go and what I drink depends on my mood, budget and what style had me most intrigued at the time”. The same question came up when I was running my pizza tour, I’d throw out a top ten instead of an answer to the best pizza in town.
So after a long time of ducking the question of what my favorites are…..here is my top ten top ten.
Ice Cream
Ice cream was my first food obsession. When Graeter’s had their yearly T-Shirt promotion I always earned my shirt early. I still have all of my shirts in storage. I toured the United Dairy Farmers Ice Cream plant in Cincinnati – it was heavenly. I was given two table mats. One side explaining how ice cream is made and the other side detailing how milk is processed. I had these framed and still have them today. When Denise’s was open in Clintonville, I spent a day making ice cream with Stan, the owner so I could get the story right. My first featured article in Ohio Magazine was about the best ice cream spots in Ohio. Last, but not least, my first job was at Knight’s Ice Cream in Clintonville. I worked there for two years in high school and saved up to pay for 1/2 of my 1979 Camaro! So yes, I do love ice cream and I know enough about it to objectively know what is needed to made a quality ice cream.
Top Ten – Ice Cream
1) Homemade Brand Ice Cream – favorite flavors: Coconut Almond Chip and Peanut Butter Chip.
Some may be shocked by this choice, in my case, the tipping point is the price to value ratio. United Dairy Farmers – the makers of Homemade Brand, regularly run a buy one, get one promotion which usually translates to $1.75 per pint – that is a bargain considering the quality of ingredient in Homemade Brand.
2) Graeters – favorite flavors: Coconut Chip, Buckeye, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and Chocolate Coconut Almond Chip.
3) Taggart’s Ice Cream, Canton Ohio – favorite flavor – Chocolate Pecan
4) Mitchell’s Ice Cream (Cleveland)
5) Mitchell’s Ice Cream (San Francisco)
6) Handel’s Ice Cream (Youngstown / Powell)
7) Honey Hut Ice Cream (Cleveland)
8) Jeni’s Ice Cream
9) Mardi Gras Ice Cream
10) Johnson’s Ice Cream
Top Ten Pizza Joints
(OK a disclaimer here – these are not listed in exact order – my favorite depends on my mood but these are all my top ten)
1) Adriatico’s – both the Sicilian and New York Style (always with extra sauce)
2) Hounddogs – Smokin’ Joes style. The taco pizza is a recent favorite
3) Iacono’s – specifically in Buffet form. It is not likely the buffet will come back anytime soon but that is a price to value decision. One of my favorite simple pizza’s is cheese only at Iacono’s. They sprinkle a little Romano on top when it comes out of the oven.
4) Tommy’s – Tommy’s last name is Iacono and these two pizza places are connected. The founder of Iaconos was Tommy’s son. However, these two pizzas are very different.
5) Pizza House – in addition to pizza, I really love their open faced meatball sandwich.
6) Cheese Board – Berkley, California
7) Zackary’s – Berkley, California
8) Bexley Pizza Plus
9) Meister’s
10) (TIE) Both RIP – Tristano’s and Lost Planet Pizza and Pasta
Addendum (11) Punch Pizza – Minneapolis
Top Ten Restaurants I Miss:
1) Galaxy Cafe
2) Lost Planet Pizza and Pasta
3) Tapatio
4) Niki’s (Greek)
5) Cancun (best Mole Enchiladas ever)
6) Dagwoodz
7) Tristano’s
8) Kahiki (not so much for the food but for the atmosphere)
9) Alana’s
10) Daddy-O’s – specifically double batter fries at 1 am
Top Ten Donuts in Ohio
Followers of the Ohio Donut Trail take note.
1) Donald’s Donuts – Zanesville
2) DK Diner – Grandview
3) Family Donut Shoppe – Londonderry
4) Bill’s Donuts – Centerville
5) Jack Frost Donuts – Cleveland
6) Brewnuts – Cleveland
7) Holtman’s Donuts – Cincinnati
8) The Original Crispie Creme Donuts – Chillicothe
9) Buckeye Donuts
10) Auddinos Bakery (Home of the doughsant / cronut)
Top Ten Foods I can not enjoy life without
1) Cheese – of all types. A few favorites: Any Blue Cheese from New Zealand, King Island from Australia, Cowgirl Creamery – San Francisco, Pearl Valley – Ohio
2) Ice cream (see above)
3) Pizza (see above)
4) Pattycake Bakery Tollhouse cookie
5) Eggs Rolls with house sauce from The Rice Bowl
6) Almonds and Cashews
7) Peanut Butter – chunky
8) Killer Brownies – Dorothy Lane Market
9) Dark Chocolate
10) Hot Dogs – ideally from O’Betty’s in Athens
Top Ten Breweries
(OK, please note beer snobs and the trolls from Columbus Craft Beer Consortium – the whole is greater than the sum of the parts so in addition to beer I am including – ambiance, customer service, etc. Other than #1, the rest are not in specific ranked order.
1) Little Fish – Athens.
2) Barley’s – Angelo! The Pre-game for my wedding and the co-creators of Tobias!
3) Seventh Son – Where I had my wedding and co creators of Tobias.
4) Restoration Brew Worx – Frank!
5) Smokehouse – Lenny!
6) Sideswipe – Famous Craig and Brewer Stew!
7) New Glarus
8) Three Floyds
9) Granville Brewing
10) Tie: Pretentious Barrel House – it should not work but it does / Endeavor Brewing
True disclaimers, there are so many great breweries in Columbus, it is so hard to limit to less than 25.
Top Ten Best Food Trips
If I only has ten days to live, would teleport to each of these cities for my final meals.
1) Berkley
2) Austin
3) Athens (Ohio)
4) Chicago
5) Cleveland
6) Bend, Oregon
7) Yarra Valley, Australia – pick up a bottle of Yering Station Fortified Shiraz
8) Melbourne, Australia
9) Cinque Terre, Italy
10) Columbus – don’t knock our city, this is an incredible place to eat.
Top Ten Places I need to get to in Columbus (not in exact order)
There are so many great places to try in Columbus. The great hidden treasures are the many immigrant kitchens serving incredible food in Columbus. If you are not adventuresome enough to test these out, I would like to suggest you take a leap of faith and try a Trust Fall Dinner from my pals Columbus Food Adventures – see some videos -> HERE
1) Yemeni Restaurant
2) Hoyo’s Kitchen
3) Jiu Thai
4) Huong Vietnamese
5) Addis Restaurant
6) Dabakh Restaurant
7) Afra Grill
8) El Arepazo
9) Poong Mei
10) Mediterranean Food Imports
Top Ten Places I am eating from During Covid / Stay at Home
Some places are much more stay at safe than others, and places that do not make an effort to create good social distancing will not get my business. All of these are pick up locations.
Other than the first place, these are not in exact order.
1) At home – my wife is a great cook and we are eating about 95% of our meals in house.
2) Iaconos Pizza (Kenny Road)
3) Lavash
4) Fibonacci’s Pizza – at Studio 35
5) Gallos Kitchen
6) Neighbors Deli
7) Smokehouse Brewing
8) Hounddogs Pizza
9) Pho Asian Noodle House
10) Taco Bell (yes it happened) – just once so far.
Top Ten Places I want to eat at when Covid is over.
1) Rockmill Tavern
2) El Arepazo – Brewery District
3) Ambrose and Eve
4) Gallos Kitchen (our carry our was good, I’d like to see how in house goes)
5) Wolf’s Ridge
6) Iaconos Pizza Buffet
7) Amal Indian Restaurant Buffet
8) Studio 35 – Fibonacci’s Pizza
9) Caleb and Robin’s house – our old neighbors from Oakland Park Avenue – we have missed our friends and Griffin cried when he could not play with his pals Violet and Landon when they did a drive by this week.
10) O’Betty’s – Athens Ohio – best hot dogs ever
Those are ten of my Top Tens. I’d love to hear about your favorites, especially places that are doing a good job for pick up or delivery in Columbus.
Be Well and eat even better.
CMH Gourmand - Eating in Columbus & Ohio 